Table of Contents
A Partnership Built on Years of Trust
When it comes to securing space systems, trust is non-negotiable.
The infrastructures involved are critical. The environments are sensitive, often isolated and sometimes classified. Before conducting security assessments on systems involved in space operations, organizations must demonstrate their ability to operate with rigor, methodological precision and discretion.
This is exactly how the partnership between CNES, the French Space Agency, and Yogosha began.
Since 2019, CNES has relied on Yogosha to conduct offensive security operations across a range of publicly exposed assets, including web portals, applications and internet-facing platforms.
As Marina Hans, Head of Cybersecurity Audits at CNES, explains:
“We had been working with Yogosha since 2019 to assess a wide range of CNES’s public-facing assets through bug bounty programs. Several of our public websites, collaborative platforms and exposed services had already been tested by their teams and community of security researchers.”
Over the years, this collaboration has built a strong foundation of trust and demonstrated the value of offensive security in uncovering real-world vulnerabilities within complex environments.
However, a new question gradually emerged: how could these same principles be applied to space systems?
In April 2025, Julien Airaud, Senior Cybersecurity Expert at CNES, and Yassir Kazar from Yogosha shared the origins of the project, the cybersecurity challenges facing the space sector, and CNES’s approach to industrializing security testing.
A Growing Cybersecurity Challenge for the Space Sector
The space industry is evolving rapidly.
Satellite constellations are expanding. Systems are becoming increasingly interconnected. Supply chains are growing more complex, and the number of stakeholders involved in space missions continues to rise.
For CNES, this evolution raises a critical question: how can organizations ensure a consistent level of security across all the components that make up a space mission?
“We were looking for new approaches to complement our established practices and to industrialize the full range of security tests we conduct,” explains Julien Airaud.
The challenge extends far beyond traditional IT systems. It also encompasses embedded software, hardware components, ground control systems and simulation environments used throughout a mission’s lifecycle.
Against this backdrop, CNES sought to develop an approach that would standardize security assessments while addressing the unique requirements of the space sector.
Bringing Offensive Security to an Industrial Scale
To address this need, CNES launched a Research and Technology (R&T) challenge in 2023 focused on space systems cybersecurity. Yogosha tied for first place with CYSEC, with a proposal aimed at industrializing security testing for space systems.
The ambition was to develop a repeatable methodology that could be adopted by stakeholders across the entire space industry.
The project was built around four key pillars:
- Deploying an offensive security platform directly within CNES’s internal network.
- Conducting security testing campaigns in representative environments.
- Modeling the identified attack scenarios.
- Developing a common framework to standardize security assessments.
One major constraint had to be addressed from the outset: most of the systems involved operate within highly protected environments, many of which are air-gapped or disconnected from the internet.
“Physical proximity was a requirement. A significant portion of our systems are hosted on our own premises, within protected and sometimes completely isolated environments. We needed a solution that could accommodate these constraints,” explains Julien Airaud.
The ability to deploy Yogosha’s platform on-premises was therefore a key enabler of the project.
Developing the First Dedicated Offensive Security Framework for Space Systems
One of the project’s most significant innovations was the development of a Security Checklist specifically designed for space systems.
Before such a framework could be built, however, the most relevant attack scenarios for these environments first had to be identified.
To achieve this, CNES and Yogosha conducted an offensive security testing campaign on a dedicated experimental testbed. Three security experts selected from Yogosha’s international community of researchers worked on-site for one week, replicating realistic attack scenarios against systems representative of space environments.
The goal was not to produce another theoretical checklist, but to build a framework grounded in real-world testing.
As Yassir Kazar explained at CYSAT 2025:
“We wanted to develop realistic, practical attack scenarios that an attacker could actually exploit, and use them to establish an initial baseline that organizations across the space industry could adopt.”
The vulnerabilities uncovered, the attack paths observed and the techniques used by the researchers were then jointly analyzed and modeled by the CNES and Yogosha teams.
This work was further informed by existing industry frameworks, including SPARTA, as well as cybersecurity standards already used by CNES. The result was a common baseline designed to reflect the operational realities of the space sector.
The outcome: a structured framework comprising 7 categories and 85 security controls, enabling operators to assess their security posture consistently and repeatedly.
This approach helps organizations:
- Standardize security assessments.
- Align stakeholders around a common security baseline.
- Streamline compliance efforts.
- Embed cybersecurity into systems from the design stage.
The objective is not to replace existing standards, but to provide a practical, actionable foundation that technical teams can use directly.
Making Cybersecurity a Shared Responsibility
Beyond the technology itself, the project also sought to drive a cultural shift.
For CNES, as Marina Hans points out, cybersecurity can no longer be the sole responsibility of dedicated security teams.
“We want teams to take ownership of their own security. It can no longer be the responsibility of cybersecurity teams alone.”
Embedded software, hardware, operations and systems engineering teams were therefore directly involved in defining attack scenarios, analyzing findings and developing the framework.
This collaborative approach not only improves the quality of security assessments but also helps embed cybersecurity best practices across organizations over the long term.
As Julien Airaud emphasizes:
“None of this would have been possible without the involvement of our operational teams, embedded software experts, embedded electronics specialists and cybersecurity teams.”
Preparing for the Future of Space… and Critical Infrastructure
The collaboration between CNES and Yogosha has demonstrated that security testing for space systems can be scaled and standardized while meeting the stringent requirements of sensitive environments.
Beyond the platform deployment and initial security assessments, the initiative has laid the groundwork for a shared security framework and a collaborative approach that could benefit the entire space ecosystem.
But the lessons learned extend well beyond the space industry.
The challenges faced by CNES — isolated environments, mission-critical systems, stringent regulatory requirements and the need for standardized security controls — are shared by many strategic sectors, including transportation, energy, defense, manufacturing and critical infrastructure operators.
The methodology developed through this project demonstrates how human expertise, continuous offensive security and standardized controls can be combined to provide a more realistic understanding of an organization’s security posture.
This model can be replicated across industries. Frameworks can evolve, and attack scenarios can be adapted to sector-specific requirements, but the underlying principles remain the same: empower technical teams to take ownership of security, integrate cybersecurity as early as possible into the system lifecycle, and turn security testing into a continuous improvement process.
As the CNES experience demonstrates, organizations operating in the most critical sectors are no longer simply looking to uncover vulnerabilities. They are looking to build a systematic, scalable capability to identify, understand and remediate them over time.
Ultimately, this shift will shape the future of critical systems security.
Download the Space Systems Security Checklist developed by CNES and Yogosha below.




